Thursday, February 19, 2026

The Bookstore Diaries by Susan Mallory - A Review

The Bookstore Diaries immediately caught my attention with its blend of bookstore charm, sister dynamics, and a wonderfully unique diary premise. While not everything landed perfectly for me, I still found this to be a cozy, engaging read with plenty of heart—especially in the audiobook format, which brings the town and characters to life with warmth.

The diary element is one of the most intriguing parts of the story. I loved the idea of townspeople storing their private journals in lockboxes at the Painted Lady Bookstore, and the mix‑up that forces Jax to read through them added a fun, creative twist. It opens the door for secrets, surprises, and small emotional revelations. I kept waiting and waiting for it to become a focus in the story since it is the name of the book. I wish this thread had been explored a bit more deeply because the concept itself is so strong and memorable.

The Painted Lady Bookstore is a setting I could happily linger in, and the coastal California backdrop adds a breezy, inviting atmosphere. And I have to say—the African Grey parrot completely won me over. He was easily my favorite character! Funny, expressive, and full of personality, he brings delightful bursts of humor that brighten the story in all the right moments.

While I didn’t always connect fully with the main characters, I appreciated the themes of sisterhood, community, and letting go of control. Readers who enjoy gentle, low‑stakes fiction with a strong sense of place will likely find this a comforting escape, especially on audio.

Overall, The Bookstore Diaries is a cozy, uplifting, and nicely imagined read with a heartfelt premise and plenty of charm. It lands between 3.5 and 4 stars for me—an atmospheric, enjoyable story that fans of small-town fiction and bookstore settings will likely savor, especially in audio.

★★★★

Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

No comments:

Post a Comment