A Court of Thorns and Roses (A Court of Thorns and Roses, #1) by Sarah J. Maas - A Review

A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas surprised me in the best way.

I’m quick to walk away from a book if it doesn’t grab me early on. My expectations aren’t complicated, but they matter: strong writing, interesting characters, a world I can sink into, a romance I can believe in, and an ending that feels satisfying. Even though I’m usually pretty skeptical of YA fantasy, ACOTAR checked all those boxes for me.

Right from the start, the world of Prythian felt vivid and easy to imagine. The map at the beginning helped a lot, and the descriptions of the Spring Court were so immersive that it often felt like I was right there with Feyre. The magic and politics of the fae world are introduced naturally, without long info dumps, which made everything feel old, dangerous, and believable.

This is a Beauty and the Beast–inspired story, but it never feels like a copy. Maas takes familiar elements—a curse, a powerful fae lord, a human girl—and turns them into something darker, richer, and more emotionally grounded. The curse in particular was handled well and felt more thoughtful and unpredictable than many retellings I’ve read.

Feyre is a strong but very human main character. She’s stubborn, guarded, and shaped by hardship, which makes her growth feel real. She makes mistakes, but her choices always make sense for who she is and what she’s been through. Watching her slowly open herself up to connection, love, and trust was one of my favorite parts of the book.

The romance is a true slow burn, which I really appreciated. There’s no instant love here—Feyre and Tamlin’s relationship develops gradually, with small moments that build into something deeper. Tamlin starts out distant and reserved, but he becomes more interesting as the story goes on, and their chemistry grows naturally. That said, readers should know this book leans more New Adult than YA, with a few scenes that are more explicit than expected.

The side characters add a lot to the story. Lucien brought humor and heart, Rhysand added intrigue with his morally gray presence, and even the villain, Amarantha, felt genuinely unsettling rather than over-the-top.

The pacing is steady and intentional. Most of the book focuses on atmosphere and character development, with the action really picking up toward the end. When it does, the stakes feel high and the payoff is satisfying. I also appreciated that while this is the first book in a series, it doesn’t end on a frustrating cliffhanger.

Overall, A Court of Thorns and Roses earns its popularity. It’s easy to get into without feeling shallow, romantic without letting the romance take over, and immersive without dragging. It’s the kind of book that pulls you in and sticks with you after you’re done.

If you enjoy fantasy with romance, court politics, and emotional depth—and you don’t mind darker themes and mature content—this one is absolutely worth the hype.

★★★★★

(Purchase on Amazon, a small commission may be earned)